Spekboom Is Not a Climate Miracle – What It Is Actually Good For

The world has spent years calling spekboom a climate miracle. A Garden Route news report this week says: slow down. As a nursery that sells the plant, we’d rather you bought it for the right reason than the wrong one.

Part of the Wildfarm network — Western Cape Independence — news & facts

The George Herald reported on Tuesday that spekboom restoration now attracts serious international money — a US$120-million World Bank bond tied to a 50,000-hectare project in the Eastern Cape, and a long-term carbon-credit purchase agreement with Amazon. The project promises 11,000 jobs, and its developer, Imperative Global Solutions, wants to restore 100,000 hectares within four to five years.

That kind of money buys a lot of hype. It also buys a lot of scrutiny, and that is where the story gets interesting for anyone standing in a Garden Route garden with a spade.

What spekboom actually is

Spekboom is Portulacaria afra, a drought-resistant succulent with fleshy, tangy, edible leaves. It is not a tree from everywhere — it belongs to the Albany thicket biome in South Africa’s south-east, and its natural range runs roughly between the Fish and Gouritz rivers. That is the single most important fact in this whole debate, and we will come back to it.

Where it genuinely earns its keep

Here is the part the sceptics don’t dispute. Intact spekboom thicket can store about 200 tonnes of carbon per hectare, according to 2021 research from Nelson Mandela University and Stellenbosch University. By 2000, roughly 45% of that thicket had been altered by livestock — mainly goat browsing — with losses of more than 80 tonnes of carbon per hectare in the worst areas.

And degraded thicket does not simply bounce back. Planting spekboom cuttings can restart the process: they throw shade, drop leaf litter, rebuild soil and improve water infiltration, and over decades other indigenous thicket species come back underneath them. That is real, measurable ecological repair — in the Eastern Cape, on degraded thicket land, with the right plant.

Where the climate claim falls apart

What the science does not support is the idea that spekboom is a uniquely powerful carbon sink that can be planted anywhere and called climate action.

  • Spekboom does not necessarily pull more carbon out of the air than other trees and vegetation in the same ecosystem. Its value is habitat repair, not carbon magic.
  • Published estimates for established stands range from about 1.4 to 4.5 tonnes of carbon per hectare per year — roughly 5 to 16.5 tonnes of CO2 — and the numbers depend heavily on assumptions.
  • Survival is patchy. In one experiment across 300 plots, the 40 plots with the most favourable conditions still only reached about 45% survival for large cuttings and 25% for small cuttings after roughly three years. Some plots had nothing left alive.
  • Planted outside its natural range, spekboom does not restore the local ecosystem — it can work against local biodiversity instead.

Dr Christina Mars of the Hessequa Herbarium told the George Herald that spekboom’s popularity has encouraged planting in places where the species does not belong, and that real restoration depends on ecological diversity rather than one species planted at scale.

The carbon-credit problem is bigger than spekboom

The article does not stop at the plant. It points at the market built on top of it: carbon credits that let a company keep emitting while presenting itself as green; commercial terms — credit prices, landowner revenue shares — that have not been publicly disclosed; and a 2025 University of Oxford and University of Pennsylvania review that found recurring problems across offset schemes, including permanence, double counting and whether the claimed reductions would have happened anyway. A 2023 study in Science of 26 avoided-deforestation projects across six countries found most had not significantly reduced deforestation, and that the reductions achieved were smaller than claimed.

None of that means every project is a fraud. It does mean an offset is not an eraser. The buyer still emits; the project compensates for part of it. Restoring land is worth doing on its own terms — not as a receipt for business as usual.

What this means for a Wilderness or Knysna garden

This is the practical bit, and it is why the story matters locally.

Your plot between the Fish and the Gouritz is mostly not Albany thicket. Wilderness, Knysna and the George surrounds are afromontane forest, fynbos and coastal thicket mosaics — different plants, different soil, different fire and rainfall patterns. Dr Wilhelm de Beer of the Gouritz Cluster Biosphere Reserve in Riversdale makes the local priority plain: clearing invasive alien plants and rehabilitating the indigenous vegetation that actually belongs there delivers more long-term benefit than importing spekboom into places it never grew.

So if your goal is “I want to do something good for the environment on my property”, planting a row of spekboom is not that thing. These are:

  • Clear the aliens first. Wattle, hakea, pine and bugweed outcompete and dry out local systems. Removing them is the highest-value work a Garden Route landowner can do.
  • Restore what belongs on your erf. Local forest and fynbos species, matched to your slope, soil and water.
  • Plant at the right density. Even in thicket restoration, researchers recommend lower densities so spekboom does not crowd out other species. A monoculture is not a restoration.

As UCT grassland ecologist William Bond puts it: plant the right tree, in the right place, for the right reasons.

If you still want spekboom — and you can

None of this makes spekboom a bad plant. It makes it a specialist that got sold as a saviour.

In a coastal Garden Route garden it earns its spot as a tough, fast-growing, water-wise filler: a wind-tolerant hedge, a hot dry wall, a sandy free-draining bank, a big pot on a stoep where nothing else survives. It roots easily from a cutting, needs almost no water once established, and the leaves are edible — tart, and good in a salad if you are the foraging type.

Just do not plant it on a wetland edge, in deep shade, or as a substitute for the local vegetation that was there before the aliens arrived. And do not plant it as a carbon offset for your lifestyle. It cannot carry that weight, and it was never asked to.

Quick answers

Is spekboom good for climate change? It is good for repairing degraded Albany thicket in the Eastern Cape. It is not a general-purpose carbon sink and does not replace cutting emissions.

Should I plant spekboom in the Garden Route? As a tough garden plant, yes, in the right spot. As an ecological restoration project, no — restore your local forest and fynbos and clear invasive aliens instead.

Why is everyone talking about it now? Because of the scale of the money: a US$120-million World Bank bond and Amazon carbon-credit purchases, with questions about measurement, survival rates and transparency.

Where does spekboom grow naturally? In the Albany thicket biome, broadly between the Fish and Gouritz rivers. Outside that range it is a garden plant, not a restoration tool.

Come and talk plants

If you are not sure what belongs on your piece of Garden Route ground, that is the conversation we like best. Send us a photo of the spot and what the soil and sun do there, and we will tell you honestly what will thrive — spekboom included, if it is the right plant for that corner.

WhatsApp us on 067 416 6773 or browse what we have growing in the shop.

Source: Wikus Engelbrecht, “Spekboom is no climate miracle, experts warn”, George Herald, 27 October 2026. Read the original report.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shopping Cart